1897 
Thomas Green Curtner |
1955 Nelson
Heflin |
| 1898
Thomas Green Curtner |
1956 Jack
Johnson |
| 1899
J.L. Homes |
1957
Fred Dock |
| 1900
J.L. Homes |
1958
Fred Dock |
| 1901
I.C. Cole (The
first Mayor of Stigler) |
1959 Dick
Wingfield |
| 1902
Matthew Creekmore |
1960 Chester
Speer |
| 1903
R.S. Alexander |
1961
Raymond Reno |
| 1904
I.C. Cole |
1962 Dwight
Blankenship |
| 1905
J.L. Homes |
1963
Sam B. Roe |
| 1906
J.L. Homes |
1964 Billy
Anderson |
| 1907
C.C. Sloan |
1965 Billy
Anderson |
| 1908
Ross F. Terrell |
1966
Alfred Wiggington |
| 1909
Ross F. Terrell |
1967
Jerry Jackson |
| 1910
Ross F. Terrell |
1968 Sam Kinnon |
| 1911
Ross F. Terrell |
1969
Omer Moore |
| 1912
M.L. Cotton |
1970 Jim Beach |
| 1913
T.H. Davidson |
1971
H. Haskell Head |
| 1914
T.H. Davidson |
1972 Sam Moore |
| 1915
O.L. Thomas |
1973
Rex Pettijohn |
| 1916
T.H. Davidson |
1974
Carl James |
| 1917
Ross F. Terrell |
1975 Norman
Dennis |
| 1918
O.L. Thomas |
1976
J.W. Terrell |
| 1919
R.B. Williams |
1977 Marvin
Smith |
| 1920
O.L. Thomas |
1978 Harold
Sharpe |
| 1921
Eugene Walker |
1979 Chester
Speer |
| 1922
O.M. Hudson |
1980
J.W. Terrell |
| 1923
W.W. Stumbaugh |
1981 Sam Kinnon |
| 1924
C.M. Stumbaugh |
1982
Robert Neldon |
| 1925
B.M. Welton |
1983 Norman
Dennis |
| 1926
Vernon Cole |
1984 Glen
Speer |
| 1927
A.C. Stumbaugh |
1985 Glen
Speer |
| 1928
B.M. Welton |
1986 Don Ritz |
| 1929
Furman Cole |
1987
J.D. "Bucky" Williams |
| 1930
F.L. Dobyns |
1988 James
(Jim) Love |
| 1931
Shuler Gamble |
1989 Jerry
Terrell |
| 1932
L.H. Morgan |
1990 Jerry
Terrell |
| 1933
B.B. Green |
1991 Mike
Ihrig |
| 1934
C.M. Stumbaugh |
1992 Mike
Ihrig |
| 1935
Roy McCaslin |
1993 James
Adcock |
| 1936
Roy McCaslin |
1994 Bruce
Cox |
| 1937
Robert Blakley |
1995 William
C. Cox |
| 1938
G.D. Gowin |
1996 John
Neal |
| 1939
Paul James |
1997 Carroll
Huggins |
| 1940
Denver Rogers |
1998
Bobby Honeycutt |
| 1941
J.F. Hudson |
1999 Sam Box |
| 1942
D. Dick Shelton |
2000 David
Clay |
| 1943
Carlos E. Shepherd |
2001 Charles (Chuck) Crase |
| 1944
Carlos E. Shepherd |
2002 James
D. Love |
| 1945
Homer F. Cole |
2003 Charles
Huggins |
| 1946
J.F. Hudson |
2004 Carl
Sharpe |
| 1947
Carl James |
2005 Henry
Roye |
| 1948
James Alfred Wigington |
2006 Chester
Speer |
| 1949
B.A. Welton |
2007 George
(Bud) Cole |
| 1950
G.L. Reid |
|
| 1951
Leo Donahue |
|
| 1952
Hubert Nicholson |
|
| 1953
Willard Perrymore |
|
| 1954
Mac L. McCrory Sr. |
|